(4)Luigi vs. Waluigi vs (5)Cecil Harvey vs. Golbez 2011

Ulti's Analysis
This.

This match is the best proof for how bad this contest was. For like two full rounds, this was our closest match. Yeah, a Waluigi win was our closest match for all but like the two final weeks of a contest. Just screw me in the eye with a spoon, and I actually like Waluigi. But he and Luigi are not rivals, and this is a good example for the bad contest format. Why couldn't we have Mario vs Luigi AND Mario vs Bowser AND Mario vs Sonic? It's not terrible.

Oh and props to the FF4 duo here. In a match they were never going to win anyway, they thoroughly embarrassed the Nintendo boys and made all of us who assumed Luigi could carry Waluigi past the trainers (ahem) out to be complete idiots.

Seriously, that was by far my worst. pick. ever.