(6)Pac-Man vs. Blinky vs (2)Solid Snake vs. Liquid Snake 2011

Ulti's Analysis
Were this a contest worth putting effort to, I'd document how Pac-Man is legendary for never putting asses in seats. He routinely shows up on lists for matches with the lowest total votes, and I think Luster Soldier did some actuary that proved this would have been the lowest scoring match of the entire contest were it a 12 hour match. So there you go.

This match also showed that MGS has lost a step. We already knew it thanks to Game of the Decade, but Snake is pretty much slowly falling off now. 67% on Pac-Man in a badly scored match is a far cry from upsetting Sephiroth and scaring the hell out of Cloud, meaning it would be almost impossible for the snakes to upset the FF7 duo next round. Liquid alone was enough of an obstacle for that, then this match happened and removed all doubt.