(1)Resident Evil 4 vs (4)Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4 2010

Ulti's Analysis
We almost got through the contest without Persona 4's YELLOW YELLOW YELLOW YELLOW YELLOW, but it was not to be.

Of all the games to make it to round 3, Persona 4 was clearly the one that didn't belong. It shows you how bad that whole TWEWY/DR/P4/Braid fourpack was, and P4 did nothing in this match to prove itself. 70-30 in round 3 is bad no matter how you slice it, but it was nice to see just to get the Persona Defense Force to finally shut the F up about that dumb series. Those people are lucky Deus Ex happened, or they would have been the worst fanbase of the contest. They could be good games for all I know, but there's no need to remind people every 15 seconds.

As for RE4, the game that actually deserved to make it this far, it made a nice recovery from that embarrassing percentage bleed against Vice City. This match paired with FFX's terrible showing on Golden Sun meant the RE4 > FFX upset train had a conductor once again.