(6)Fire Emblem vs (11)Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 2010

Ulti's Analysis
This was a mildly debated match pre-contest, but then this poll happened and all that debate looked pretty dumb: http://board8.wikia.com/wiki/(6)WWF_No_Mercy_vs_(11)Fire_Emblem:_Path_of_Radiance_2010

A sports game people actually like got wrecked by Path of Radiance, so imagine how a sports game people legitimately hate would do. To be fair Tony Hawk didn't get completely killed like its distant wrestling cousin, but this match was never in doubt at all. Some actually wondered if Fire Emblem could take down KOTOR.

Personally, I'd love to see a Fire Emblem 7 vs Path of Radiance match. Radiance probably wins, but who really knows.