(7)Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 vs (2)Kingdom Hearts 2010

Ulti's Analysis
The 2009 Game of the Year poll on our site ended up laughably bad, but the mascot of it tanked the worst of all. It goes out and does nothing in a win against Dissidia, then gets itself doubled by Kingdom Hearts.

A doubling may sound huge, but look at the past matches for those characters, especially Sora. Kingdom Hearts never blows anything out, and never gets blown out itself, much like Master Chief. For Kingdom Hearts to double anything, much less our 2009 GOTY winner, is thoroughly embarrassing. I know this site hates Call of Duty and for good reason, but my goodness. What wastes of space those games were in this.