(3)Uncharted 2: Among Thieves vs (11)Street Fighter IV 2010

Ulti's Analysis
Earlier I brought up the concept of every contest having pyrrhic victories, and this was definitely one such match for Uncharted 2. Sure it won the match with no sweat, but take a look at what happened here. Early on, Uncharted was near 60% and started bleeding percentage all over the place. Then in the dead hours Street Fighter 4 started a prolonged stall before Uncharted recovered in the morning, though "recovered" might be the wrong term to use here.

I love Street Fighter 4, but I won't go and say it's some really strong game because it beat some 3D Sonic game on GameFAQs, a site that hates 3D Sonic. Yet this game scored 46% on Uncharted 2, which brought up all kinds of "lol PS3 exclusives" stuff. Uncharted 2 would end up not looking so bad, but after this match it was clear whichever Halo game it went up against was going to beat it -- especially given this was Halo in a day match it was dealing with.