(4)Dark Souls vs (13)Sid Meier's Civilization V 2015

Ulti's Analysis
When I first saw the bracket I almost picked Civ 5 to pull the upset, but that's because I'm dumb and haven't played the Dark Souls series yet. Outside of FLOWCHART™ reasons, Dark Souls could very well be the most popular modern series in gaming. Gamers absolutely revere the series for being mercilessly old-school, and in a gaming world with checkpoints every 2 seconds and linear everything, Dark Souls decides to not give a crap and just chops your balls off whenever possible.

Gamers rewarded this by giving Dark Souls the easy doubling over Civilization 5, and it was rather obvious after round 1 that MGS5 was completely screwed in round 2. There was no way it had a prayer of beating this game. It's fun to think about how far Dark Souls could have gone if it was in Division 7 or 8, but alas.