(1)Mario vs. Bowser vs (5)Ike vs. Black Knight 2011

Ulti's Analysis
Round 2 is usually the worst round in any contest, since it's the round that separates the chaff from the wheat. Fittingly, this contest's round 2 was by FAR the worst one we've ever had. Only one match would end up any good and thanks to trend knowledge it was over even when it was close. Also round 2 began every match being 24 hours, which is good insomnia treatment.

This match was just dumb all around. I understand bad bracket placement now and then, but only a year ago we saw this same exact match: http://board8.wikia.com/wiki/(1)Mario_vs_(4)Ike_2010

Bad rematches are the worst.