(12)Mario Kart Wii vs (4)Pokémon Gold/Silver/Crystal 2010

Ulti's Analysis
I'm obviously biased, but that GSC picture is the best singular picture in rounds 2 and 3 (before freeform started). But this picture isn't the best one from round 2, though, that honor goes to Prime vs DMC3.

As for the actual match, GSC went out and outdid the Majora > Chrono Cross percentage by enough to keep that match debatable. It was certainly a much better effort by GSC than that embarrassing percentage bleed against Advance Wars, so to this point it was fair to say the match was up in the air. Obviously it didn't turn out that way, but those of us with GSC still had those laughable 4-way polls to fall back on.

And of course, we have more LOL Wii action going on. One of the Wii's flagship titles from a popular series can't even get 30% in a poll against Pokémon, really? What in the F happened to the Wii? What happened to Mario Kart, for that matter? Did people finally realize the series isn't any good past the N64?